Report Archive:
ˇ October 19: Fox Lawyers Insist On Secrecy At Deposition French TV Ejected
ˇ October 18: FDA Wants Comments on G-M Foods Public Meetings Start in November
ˇ October 13: Judge Rules: Trial Will Proceed:
Defense loses third effort to have case dismissed
ˇ September 24: MSNBC:
Gene-modified foods might get labels:
Industry weighs voluntary steps, U.S. studies options as well
ˇ September 20: Trial Still Set to Start Soon:
Busy Docket Delays foxBGHsuit
ˇ August 4: MSNBC:
Mutable Feast:
Will the fight over gene-altered food products leapfrog across the Atlantic?
ˇ June 30: Consumers International:
UN Health Group Shuns BGH
ˇ June 1: New York Times:
Farmers’ Right To Sue Grows - Food Warning Muzzle Likely
ˇ May 10: Corporate Crime Reporter:
Monsanto Officials Join Leading Consumer, Environmental Groups
ˇ May 3: Fox Deceives Viewers in Primetime,
Too
Net Admits Staging after INSIDE EDITION Report
ˇ April 30: Democracy Group Award to
Akre/Wilson
Fired Reporters Cited for "Courage in Journalism"
ˇ April 29: New Trial Date is October
11
Fox Piles On Big-Name Lawyers
ˇ April 17: Clinton Lawyer Joins Fox
Legal Team
David Kendall Involvement Confirmed in Letter to Monsanto
ˇ April 16: Fox Pleads for Another Delay
Later Trial Date to be Set April 29th
ˇ April 1: Judge Says BGH Case Will
Go To Trial
Opening Gavel Falls May 10th
ˇ February 16: PENTHOUSE Exposes BGH,
Fox Coverup:
First-rate story of BGH situation and lawsuit against Fox TV
(rated G -- no nudity, just the story)
ˇ January 25: ENS
Summary of BGH Developments
ˇ January 14: How Fox Wanted to Slant News
of Canadian Concerns
Canadian BGH Concerns Were Big Issue In Firing of Fox Reporters
ˇ January 14: Canada Says NO to BGH!
Read the CBC Story or 
ˇ January 14: Health Canada Rejects Bovine Growth Hormone in Canada
Government News Release
ˇ December 16: Akre & Wilson Win Courage
Award
For Work On Story Which Cost Them Their Jobs
ˇ December 15: ABC NEWS Catches Up on BGH
Read the ABC Story or 
ˇ November 7: FOX Legal (8/28) Answers
to Reporters' Complaint Now Available
ˇ November 1: Monsanto
and Fox: Partners in Censorship
PR Watch - Showcase Article
ˇ October 30: Canadians Probe Coverup Claim
Read CBC Story or 
ˇ October 24: Reporters Get Top SPJ Ethics
Award
ˇ October 22: BGH Issue Explodes in Canada:
Read CBC Story or 
ˇ October 7: SECRET Canadian Study Leaked...
...BGH safety questions unanswered?
ˇ Sept 13: Akre-Wilson Depos Start
ˇ Sept 10: TIMES/St. Petersburg
SP Times covers NutraSweet flap
ˇ Sept 10: Our Story: Fox Still Protecting
Monsanto?
ˇ Sept 8: Fox Pulls Plug on NutraSweet
Foe
ˇ Sept 1: Reporters Respond To Defense
ˇ READ
story FOX-TV refused to air...
or 
ˇ July 14: Judge refuses to dismiss
all but one count of reporters' suit
ˇ July 5: OBSERVER/London
Digger Still Plays Dirty
ˇ July 1: Depositions Continue, Trial Date
Set
ˇ June 7: TIMES/St. Petersburg
Akre/Wilson Preparing FCC Complaint
ˇ May 26: Judge rejects Defense motion
for Protective Order
ˇ May 25: WEEKLY PLANET/Tampa:
Grazing A Stink
- - -Don't Have a Cow
ˇ May 23: NEW YORK TIMES:
(Silenced) Reporters... Post Web Site
ˇ May 21: Wilson/Akre demand on-air correction
ˇ April 29: FOX-TV asks court:
Dismiss case
and Delay depositions
|
FOX
LAWYERS FUMING
WALTER CRONKITE TESTIFIES ON
BEHALF OF STEVE AND JANE
By STEVE WILSON
NEW YORK (April 25, 2000)—Amidst a hailstorm of objections from the
lead counsel representing Fox, Walter Cronkite has testified on behalf
of two veteran journalists suing the network’s O-and-O in Tampa. |
|
CRONKITE TESTIFIES
|
Cronkite appeared for more than an hour Tuesday in a conference room at
CBS headquarters here to provide expert testimony about the
pre-broadcast/legal review process and the proper role of those involved—the
journalists, their news editors and executives, and the attorneys
hired to protect the interests of the broadcasting company. |
In a lawsuit set for trial June 12, reporters
Steve Wilson and Jane Akre have charged they were suspended, locked out
and ultimately fired from WTVT for refusing orders from station lawyers
and management to slant a series of investigative reports.
Fox has denied any
wrongdoing and claims the journalists refused reasonable editorial
oversight.
Cronkite, the dean of
broadcast journalism and frequently referred to as "the most trusted
man in America," stepped down as managing editor and anchor of The CBS
Evening News in 1981. Since then he has continued to work as a Special
Correspondent for CBS News and has frequently spoken out against the
direction TV news has taken in the last several years.
Always a
supporter of the highest ethical standards in journalism, Cronkite has
recently assailed what he’s called the "dumbing down" of news
broadcasts and the philosophy that the bottom line has lately become the
only line at many news organizations now owned and controlled by large
corporations with few if any roots in journalism. (see
Cronkite's latest statement)
Without offering any
judgments on the specific facts at issue in the Tampa case, Cronkite
testified that every journalist has a strong duty to resist reporting false
and distorted information, and responsible news organizations do not let
lawyers dictate editorial decisions.
"There
is no one better than Walter Cronkite to help us explain to a Tampa jury
just what are the bounds of good and ethical journalism," said
plaintiff Wilson.
"Given
what sometimes passes for news these days, local viewers could do with a
reminder of what journalists and news broadcasters are supposed to stand
for," he added. |
Patricia Anderson, once lead defense counsel in the case before Fox
replaced her with McDaniels, did not appear at the Cronkite deposition,
although Fox sent one its New York attorneys to observe. Asked why she was
absent from such an important deposition, Anderson said,
"I didn't want to see an old man embarrassed."
It was not
immediately clear which older gentleman she meant, Cronkite or her own legal
colleague McDaniels. |

ANDERSON & McDANIELS
|
Cronkite joins consumer advocate and
presidential candidate Ralph Nader on the plaintiff’s expert witness list.
Over the objections of Fox lawyers, the trial court judge has not objected
to Nader being called to explain the public interest requirement that all
broadcasters are legally required to follow.
Fox has admitted it was under strong
pressure from Monsanto, a subject of Wilson and Akre’s reports about
bovine growth hormone and its effects on the public milk supply in Florida
and throughout much of the country. Monsanto, a Fox advertiser, threatened
"dire consequences" if the Wilson/Akre reports were broadcast.
WTVT, one of 22 stations that are part of Rupert Murdoch’s media empire,
has denied any wrongdoing.
"Mr. Cronkite is going to be this
jury’s journalistic compass," explained co-plaintiff Jane Akre.
"He is going to remind the jurors about the high road many news
organizations no longer travel these days.
He will make it perfectly clear
what should and should not happen in the final review process when stories
are edited for broadcast. He’ll make it clear what ought to happen when
the public interest clashes with a news organization’s own selfish
interest to maximize its profits.
"And after he lays the
foundation about the journalist’s duty to resist pressures to distort the
news, we’ll present a host of other witnesses and solid evidence that Fox
fired Steve Wilson and me merely for insisting on high ethical standards
that WTVT managers and lawyers wanted to ignore," Akre added.
William McDaniels, lead defense counsel
for Fox in this case, lodged vociferous objections to Cronkite’s testimony
in an impromptu telephone hearing with the trial judge just prior to the
deposition. Judge Ralph Steinberg held the long-distance telephone hearing
after he was called because the parties could not agree on the procedural
grounds for the deposition to go forward.
Since McDaniels reserved his
objections for trial, Fox is now expected to try and convince Judge
Steinberg that since Cronkite is neither a lawyer nor an expert on broadcast
law, his testimony should not be heard by the jury.
"What kind of a news
organization needs to put distance between itself and Walter Cronkite, the
unassailable champion of ethical journalism in America?" asked
plaintiff Wilson.
"When Walter Cronkite says
‘That’s the way it is,’ viewers know he’s not influenced by any
interest other than the truth and the public interest. That is precisely
what this lawsuit is all about—and exactly the standard that Fox fears the
jury may apply in this case," he said.
New postings added frequently to the following:
ˇ RESOURCES
ˇ CLIPS
ˇ BBS
ˇ Restore FRONT PAGE
Note: Clicking these links will put requested page in MAIN frame.
To view, or access other files... close this browser window:
|
|